At 42.5 points per dollar spent, the Premier card laps the field. Priority asks $3,000 for 90K (30 points per dollar), Plus wants $3,000 for 80K (26.7 points per dollar). The math is brutal for the other two.
Annual fees tell the rest of the story. Priority runs $149, Premier $99, Plus $69. If you're chasing a Companion Pass — still the single best perk in domestic flying — the Premier hits the sweet spot. Lower fee, lower spend, and those 85K points count toward the 135K qualifying threshold if you're approved by December 2, 2026. The bonus points count even if you meet the spending threshold in early 2027; Southwest has confirmed this.
Here's the catch: these elevated offers aren't available through referral links right now. That means no 20K referral bonus for your friend, partner, or household co-conspirator. Reports suggest referrals will return eventually, so if you can wait and have a referral source, patience pays. If you need the points now — or don't have a referral hookup — the public links are live.
Priority only makes sense if you genuinely use the upgraded boarding positions and the $75 annual travel credit. That credit is effectively cash if you fly Southwest even once a year, which narrows the effective fee gap to $50 versus Premier. But you're still spending an extra $1,000 for 5,000 more points. That's 10 cents per point in incremental spend — fine if you were spending anyway, silly if you're manufacturing.
Plus at 80K/$3K is the weak link. The fee is lowest, but the earn rate is worst. Only take this if you're strictly fee-averse and the $30 difference versus Premier matters more than 5,000 points and a lower spend hurdle.
Bottom line: Premier is the play for most people. Priority if you'll actually use the perks. Plus if you're allergic to annual fees. And if you're holding out for referral links — check back in a few weeks, but don't bet your Companion Pass timeline on it.