← All Cards

Compare Cards

best in the row Direct: booked with the airline, hotel or rental company Travel portal: booked through the card's own travel site Notes under a value give its limits and conditions

Change cards
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant vs Hilton Honors American Express Aspire
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant $650 a year Hilton Honors American Express Aspire $550 a year
Annual fee $650Best: $550
Welcome bonus 150,000 Marriott Bonvoy points + $250 statement credit after $6,000 spend in 6 months (through Sep 30, 2026)200,000 Hilton Honors points after $6,000 spend in 6 months (limited-time offer through January 13, 2027); annual Free Night Reward also issued in year one
Dining 3xRestaurants worldwide; Marriott Bonvoy points (~0.7cpp)Best: 7xU.S. restaurants; Hilton Honors points (~0.5-0.6cpp)
Groceries 2xBase rateBest: 3xBase rate; Hilton Honors points
Gas 2xBase rateBest: 3xBase rate; Hilton Honors points
Airlines, direct 3xFlights booked directly with airlinesBest: 7xFlights booked directly with airlines or via Amex Travel
Airlines, travel portal NoneBest: 7xVia Amex Travel
Hotels, direct 6xAt Marriott Bonvoy hotels; stacks with Platinum Elite 50% bonusBest: 14xAt Hilton properties; 34x total with Diamond status bonus at most brands (24x at Home2, Homewood, Spark and Tru)
Hotels, travel portal NoneBest: 3xNon-Hilton hotels via Amex Travel earn the 3x base rate (only flights earn 7x via Amex Travel)
Car rental 2xBase rateBest: 7xBooked directly with select car rental companies
Other travel 2xBase rateBest: 3xNon-flight/car travel falls under base rate
Streaming 2xBase rateBest: 3xBase rate
Everything else 2xAll other eligible purchasesBest: 3xAll other eligible purchases
Rewards currency Marriott Bonvoy38 airlines, mostly 3:1Hilton HonorsEarns Hilton Honors directly, no transfer partners
Other bonus categories
  • Platinum Elite stacking50% bonus on base hotel earnings with Platinum Elite status
  • Airline transfersTransfer to 38 airlines, mostly at 3:1; 5K bonus per 60K transferred with most partners (10K for United)
  • Hilton Diamond status stacking14x card + 20x Hilton Honors earn (10x base + 100% Diamond bonus) = 34x total at most Hilton properties
  • Spend bonusesAdditional Free Night Rewards at $30K and $60K annual spend
2 rows hidden: none of these cards has them
Airline credit NoneBest: $200/yrUp to $50/quarter for flights purchased directly or via Amex Travel
Hotel credit $100/stayUp to $100 property credit for qualifying charges per 2+ night stay at Ritz-Carlton or St. Regis booked direct at an eligible special rate$400/yrUp to $200 semiannually for eligible resort purchases at participating Hilton resorts
Dining credit Best: $300/yrUp to $25/month in statement credits at restaurants worldwideNone
Other credits
  • Free Night AwardAnnual free night certificate up to 85,000 points value
  • 25 Elite Night CreditsApplied annually toward higher Marriott elite status tiers
  • CLEAR+ Credit$219/yr statement credit for CLEAR+ membership
  • Waldorf/Conrad Property CreditUp to $100 on eligible 2+ night stays at Waldorf Astoria or Conrad
2 rows hidden: none of these cards has them
Lounge access Priority Pass + 2 guestsUnlimited access to 1,300+ lounges worldwideDiamond lounge onlyExecutive lounge access at Hilton properties via Diamond status; Priority Pass removed Feb 2024
Hotel status Marriott Platinum EliteRoom upgrades (incl. suites when available), late checkout, exec lounge access at participating brands (not Ritz-Carlton, St. Regis or W), 50% bonus points, welcome giftsHilton Diamond2nd-highest Hilton tier (below Diamond Reserve): suite upgrades, exec lounge, daily F&B credit, 100% bonus on base points
Global Entry / TSA PreCheck $120 every 4 yearsUp to $85 TSA PreCheck or $120 Global Entry every 4 yearsNone
No foreign transaction fee YesNo foreign transaction feesYesNo foreign transaction fees
Other benefits
  • Free Night AwardAnnual certificate up to 85K points; covers most Marriott properties
  • Free Night Reward1 per year (any day of week), valid at most Hilton including Waldorf/Conrad; additional at $30K/$60K spend
  • 5th Night FreeBook 5 consecutive award nights and night 5 is free
1 row hidden: none of these cards has them
Trip delay $5006-hour trigger, 2 claims/yr$5006-hour trigger, round trip paid entirely with the card, 2 claims per 12 months
Baggage delay / loss $3K/tripLost, damaged or stolen bags: up to $2,000 checked, $3,000 combined per trip; no baggage delay coverage$3K/tripLost, damaged or stolen bags (up to $2,000 checked, $3,000 combined per trip); no baggage-delay coverage listed
Car rental insurance SecondaryCar rental loss and damage insurance (secondary; no liability coverage)YesCar rental loss and damage insurance (secondary)
Purchase protection $10,000/incident$50,000/yr, 90 daysYesPurchase protection and return protection
Extended warranty 1 yearOn warranties of 5 years or lessYesExtended warranty on eligible purchases
Scout's take The Brilliant is a fantastic card — for a very specific person. If you're already loyal to Marriott and staying at their properties regularly, the value stacks up fast.If Hilton is your ride-or-die hotel chain, the Aspire is still a slam dunk — even after the Priority Pass removal. A free night at a Waldorf Astoria can be worth more than the entire $550 fee.