← All Cards

Compare Cards

best in the row Direct: booked with the airline, hotel or rental company Travel portal: booked through the card's own travel site Notes under a value give its limits and conditions

Change cards
AAdvantage Aviator Red vs Citi AAdvantage Executive
AAdvantage Aviator Red $99 a year Citi AAdvantage Executive $695 a year
Annual fee Best: $99Card discontinued: closed to new applications on September 30, 2025, and accounts were converted to the Citi AAdvantage Platinum Select ($99/yr) on April 24, 2026.$695$695 for accounts opened on or after Aug 23, 2026 (previously $595). Authorized users: $175 total for up to 3 users, $175 each additional. Each AU gets Admirals Club access.
Welcome bonus No longer available. Previously: 60,000 AAdvantage miles after one purchase and paying the $99 annual fee.Earn 125,000 AAdvantage bonus miles after $15,000 spend in 5 months.
Dining 1xAAdvantage mile under Barclays (2x at restaurants since the April 24, 2026 conversion to Citi)1xAAdvantage mile
Groceries 1xAAdvantage mile1xAAdvantage mile
Gas 1xAAdvantage mile under Barclays (2x at gas stations since the April 24, 2026 conversion to Citi)1xAAdvantage mile
Airlines 2xAAdvantage miles on American Airlines purchasesBest: 4xEligible AA purchases; 5x after $150K/yr spend
Hotels, direct 1xAAdvantage mile1x
Hotels, travel portal NoneBest: 12xVia aadvantagehotels.com
Car rental, direct 1xAAdvantage mile1xAAdvantage mile
Car rental, travel portal NoneBest: 12xAAdvantage miles on car rentals via aadvantagecars.com
Other travel 1xAAdvantage mile1xAAdvantage mile
Streaming 1xAAdvantage mile1xAAdvantage mile
Everything else 1xAAdvantage mile1xAAdvantage mile
Rewards currency AAdvantageEarns AAdvantage directly, no transfer partnersAAdvantageEarns AAdvantage directly, no transfer partners
Other bonus categories None
  • 1 Loyalty Point per 1 eligible AAdvantage mile earned from purchases; 10,000 bonus Loyalty Points at 50K, 90K, 165K and 240K Loyalty Points in a status year (up to 40,000)
3 rows hidden: none of these cards has them
Airline credit $25 inflight Wi-Fi credit per anniversary year on AA flights (ends October 25, 2026)Up to $100/year back on inflight and eligible Admirals Club purchases
Other travel credit NoneUp to $120/year Avis/Budget prepaid car rental credit; up to $120 Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit every 4 years; up to $500/year American Airlines Vacations package credit ($250 Jan-Jun + $250 Jul-Dec)
Other credits None
  • Up to $15 Lyft credit per month (after 3 eligible rides in a calendar month; up to $180/year)
Lounge access NoneAdmirals Club membership (nearly 50 Admirals Clubs + 60+ partner lounges including Alaska Lounges); immediate family or up to 2 guests; each authorized user (18+) also gets Admirals Club access (not partner lounges)
Hotel status NoneOmni Hotels Champion status (enrollment required); one Omni Free Night Award per calendar year after a qualifying 2+ night stay booked directly with Omni
Global Entry / TSA PreCheck NoneUp to $120 every 4 years
Companion certificate Companion certificate ($99 plus taxes) after $20,000 annual spend on domestic economy (Citi is ending it; last one earnable through your next cardmember anniversary)None
Free checked bags First checked bag free for cardholder + up to 4 companions on same domestic AA reservationFirst checked bag free for cardholder + up to 8 companions on same domestic AA reservation
No foreign transaction fee YesYes
Other benefits
  • Preferred boarding (Group 5) for cardholder + up to 4 companions; 25% back on inflight food/beverage purchases; 0% intro APR on balance transfers for 15 billing cycles (new accounts only; no longer available)
  • Priority check-in and airport screening (where available) and Group 4 priority boarding for cardholder + up to 8 companions; complimentary Avis President's Club status
Trip delay NoneUp to $500 per traveler when delayed 6+ hours
Baggage delay / loss Lost luggage reimbursement (Mastercard World Elite benefit)Lost baggage protection up to $3,000 per traveler
Car rental insurance Auto rental collision damage waiver (Mastercard World Elite benefit)Worldwide car rental insurance up to $75,000 (secondary in U.S., primary abroad)
Purchase protection Mastercard World Elite purchase protectionUp to $10,000 per incident, $50,000/year (damage or theft within 90 days)
Extended warranty Mastercard World Elite extended warrantyAdds 24 months to the manufacturer's warranty (up to $10,000 per item)
Other protections None
  • Trip cancellation/interruption protection up to $5,000 per trip
Scout's take The Aviator Red had a great run — that one-purchase, 60,000-mile welcome bonus was legendary — but the card closed to new applicants on September 30, 2025, and Citi converted every account to the Citi AAdvantage Platinum Select on April 24, 2026.The Citi AAdvantage Executive is a one-trick pony — but it's a very good trick. The Admirals Club membership alone is worth up to $1,400/year, and you're paying $695.